What the hell! How does it have to do anything with popularity, if the song is metal or isn't? Who the hell cares! Even if it was pop or country, if it's freaking good, you freaking love it - just rock with it. Geez. Why would it even be overrated.. you know what's overrated? Stuff on your radio when you drive to grocery store, that's overrated.
I've scrobbled it 201 times, but that seems like an error. Plus the tons of times I've listened to it on youtube and other devices. It's just such a strong song, it reminds me a certain period of my life. It's one of the best songs they have ever created. If someone doesn't like it, it's okay, we can't like everything. But don't say it's bad or overrated or whatever. That is not for you to decide.