I know this is one of the most hated albums in recent music history, but I'm gonna give it a shot.
Frantic - 5 1/2 out of 10: I like the intro to this one, this song is ok, the tick tick can get very annoying though, probably not one I'd listen to again and again
St. Anger - 5 out of 10: Again, trying to give this album a chance, I just cannot get into it so far, this song is ok, but where are the guitar solos?
Some Kind of Monster - 5 out of 10: super long intro, yet again it goes nowhere, I keep waiting for a killer solo and for all the buildup to actually go somewhere, but it's not happening, this song should not be over 8 minutes long
Dirty Window - 5 1/2 out of 10: the intro here is more promising, strangely enough, I hear System of a Down in parts of this song, 4 songs in and I still haven't heard the Metallica I know and love
Invisible Kid - 7 out of 10: dare I say it, I like this song.... so far definitely the best on the album